One of the most frequently asked and perhaps most debilitating questions for professionals across all levels is whether to focus on skills vs degrees (formal education versus practical skills). Concerning providing a balanced view based on advising hundreds of hiring managers and job applicants, there is little ambiguity: this is a false choice. Top performers don’t opt to emphasize one over the other; they recognize how to effectively market a combination of both in a way that supports their career.
In today’s hiring environment, the hiring decision process is not solely focused on filling one box. Rather, it is about minimizing the risk for the hiring organization. Employers are essentially asking one simple question: “Will this individual be able to produce the results we require? ”
Your credential portfolio, including education, skills, and experience, serves as the evidence you provide to support an affirmative response to that question.
Beyond Only Knowledge—The Long-Term Advantages of Education
Although the current trend is toward emphasizing skills, diminishing the importance of formal education is a strategic misstep in numerous fields. While a formal education provides far more than the course material itself, some of the key roles include:
Signal of Commitment and Basic Capabilities: Finishing a degree program is a signal to employers that you can maintain a long-term goal, navigate a large bureaucracy, and meet recurring deadlines. For example, a degree program represents a verifiable minimum level of cognitive ability and organizational capabilities.
Non-Negotiable Credential: In regulated fields like medicine, law, engineering, and accounting, a specific, accredited degree is required before an individual can begin practicing. There is no alternative.
Structured Framework: Formal education programs offer students a wide theoretical base and a critical thinking structure that makes it easier to develop new, specific skills during their career. Students learn how to learn.
The Strategic Methodology: If pursuing a degree, seek out a program that offers a strong co-op or internship program. The experience gained while working in the field is likely to be much more valuable to your first employer than the degree itself.
Increasingly Valued Skills: Execution of Skill
Skills are the actual implementation of knowledge. Skills are what allow individuals to generate value, resolve problems, and complete tasks every day. In rapidly changing fields, the type and relevance of skills are typically the most important factors.
Immediate Proof of Competency: A portfolio, GitHub repository, or certification in a specific area of technology (i.e., AWS Cloud Practitioner, Google Analytics) provides objective, instant confirmation that an individual can accomplish something.
Relevance & Agility: Many fields are experiencing rapid change, which causes skills to become dated very quickly. Demonstrating the ability to learn a new programming language or master a new marketing tool indicates the individual has the capacity to adapt and stay relevant.
Democratizing Access: Skills-Based Hiring Provides Opportunities for Non-Traditional Applicants. This method of hiring has opened doors to higher-paying jobs in technical fields for those who could not afford or were unable to attend college traditionally.
The Strategic Methodology: Focus on developing T-shaped skills. Develop deep knowledge in one or two core subject areas (the vertical bar of the T), but also develop a wide range of related skills (the horizontal bar), such as communication, project management, or basic data analysis.
Combining Credentials with Capability: Balancing Formal Education with Continuous, Targeted Skill Development
The best-performing professionals combine formal education with ongoing, targeted skill development. They recognize that formal education and continued development each serve a distinct function in their career story.
If you have a degree:
- Your degree opens the door. Your skills secure the position. Never stop learning. Continuously build upon your foundational knowledge with micro-credentials, certifications, and portfolio projects that show you can successfully translate theory into real-world applications.
If you taught yourself or come from a non-traditional background:
- Your skills and portfolio are the greatest amount of evidence you can provide. To overcome the applicant tracking systems (ATS) used in many industries or to overcome biases in more traditional industries, you should:
- Consider obtaining targeted certifications from a reputable organization to validate your knowledge.
Create a strong personal brand—a perfectly written LinkedIn profile, a professional website, and a portfolio of exceptional quality work.
Use strategic networking to obtain a referral; referrals often bypass rigid HR filters.
What Employers Are Seeking: The Total Package
When I consult with companies regarding hiring practices, they are ultimately trying to find a candidate who minimizes their own risk. They are seeking evidence of:
- Ability: Can he/she/they do the job? (Skill, Portfolio, Certifications)
- Legitimacy: Does he/she/they have a foundational understanding of the subject matter, and can they persevere? (Degree, Equivalent Experience)
- Culture Fit: Will he/she/they fit well with the rest of the team? (Interviews and References)
- Growth Potential: Is he/she/they capable of growing and learning with the company? (History of Learning New Skills)
Ultimately, the “skills vs. education” debate is just a distraction. The key is to establish yourself as a lifelong learner who uses both formal education and continuing skill development as tools in your career toolbox.
Instead of focusing on “Should I go for a degree or focus on getting the skills?” ask:
- “What is the particular result I am seeking?” (Become a data scientist, get promoted to manager, start a freelance business.)
- “What is the fastest and most credible route to demonstrate I can achieve that end?”
- “What combination of credentials and demonstrable skills will make my value proposition impossible to ignore for the employer/client?”
You build your career on the evidence you provide. Create a strong case.
About The Author
